For sale · Reynolds Lake Oconee

189 Reynolds Drive, Eatonton, GA 31024

Putnam County · Lake Oconee · View on map · Share this home

$3,950,000 Listed June 19, 2026

Margie Sorrell, Lake Oconee REALTORLake Oconee | REALTORMargie SorrellWho am I? Read my story here
  • 5Beds
  • 8Baths
  • 8,110Sq ft
  • 1.24Acres
  • 2005Built
  • $487Per sq ft

Listing courtesy of Kim and Lin Logan Real Estate, 706-454-1621 · Lake Country Board of REALTORS® MLS #71230

189 Reynolds Drive is a five-bedroom, 8-bath lakefront house with 8,110 square feet on 1.24 acres in Reynolds Lake Oconee, a gated community in Putnam County. It was built in 2005 and is listed at $3,950,000.

On the water

189 Reynolds Drive on Lake Oconee

Dock
Max Dock
Boat lift
Included
Waterfront
Lake Front
View
Lake
From the listing

About 189 Reynolds Drive

Lake front estate located on a cove in the tranquil and prestigious enclave of great waters at Reynolds Lake Oconee. Exquisitely detailed throughout, including immaculate woodwork and moldings. Custom designed and crafted by a master artisan. Home has extensive use of reclaimed antique heart pine throughout, including hand-crafted flooring and structural beams and ceilings. The use of rare antique elements throughout the house gives this home its ambiance and old world feel that is difficult to replicate. The open concept kitchen is well designed with ease of entertaining in mind. It includes a custom designed lacanche french range, flamed and brushed granite countertops, carrara marble accents, as well as a large island magnificently crowned with rare living edge african rosewood. Commercial refrigeration and a true, fully equipped butler's pantry makes this kitchen ready for any crowd, big or small. Bi-fold doors opens up the great room to the extensive open decks with a spectacular view across the lake. A four-season screened porch features a stone fireplace (one of 3) with a wood-burning pizza oven. The primary bedroom suite is on the main level and features a sitting area and a bath with a freestanding tub. The additional bedrooms in the house all include ensuite bathrooms. Also, above the garage, there is a full bedroom suite with a full kitchen, living room, full bath, closet, and its own a/c. Included in the basement is a multi purpose room, theater, wine room, wet bar and multiple storage areas.

Market context

How 189 Reynolds Drive Compares to Other Reynolds Lake Oconee Homes for Sale

  • 25 of 143By asking price, highest first, among the 143 homes for sale in Reynolds Lake Oconee
  • $487Per square foot, against a $762 average for the other 37 lakefront homes for sale here
  • 141Days on the market
  • $3,870,000Last sale price, May 2023
Quick answers

Questions About 189 Reynolds Drive

How much is 189 Reynolds Drive?

189 Reynolds Drive is listed at $3,950,000, about $487 per square foot. It came on the market at $4,450,000.

Is 189 Reynolds Drive on the water?

Yes. 189 Reynolds Drive is a lakefront home on Lake Oconee. The listing shows a max dock.

What neighborhood is 189 Reynolds Drive in?

189 Reynolds Drive is in Reynolds Lake Oconee, in Eatonton, Georgia, on the Putnam County side of Lake Oconee.

What are the HOA fees and taxes for 189 Reynolds Drive?

The listing shows an association fee of $2,000.

How long has 189 Reynolds Drive been on the market?

189 Reynolds Drive came on the market on June 19, 2026, 141 days ago.

Who is the listing agent for 189 Reynolds Drive?

189 Reynolds Drive is listed by Kim and Lin Logan Real Estate (706-454-1621). Margie Sorrell can show it to you and answer questions about Reynolds Lake Oconee.

Price history

189 Reynolds Drive Price and Sale History

  1. Sep 28, 2026Price reduced−11.2%$3,950,000
  2. Jun 19, 2026Listed$4,450,000
  3. Jun 17, 2026Expired
  4. Price reduced−4.3%$4,450,000
  5. Aug 13, 2025Listed$4,650,000
  6. May 12, 2023Sold$3,870,000
  7. Mar 13, 2023Listed$4,250,000
  8. Sep 20, 2021Sold$3,500,000
  9. Price reduced−8.6%$3,200,000
  10. Jul 26, 2021Listed$3,500,000
Details

189 Reynolds Drive Features and Details

Inside

Style
Rustic, Craftsman
Stories
1
Flooring
Tile, Wood
Fireplace
Masonry, Multiple Fireplace
Kitchen and appliances
Built in Microwave, Dishwasher, Double Oven, Freezer, Disposal, Range, Refrigerator, Vent Hood, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Water Softener
Other rooms
Foyer, In-Law Suite, Media Room, Pantry, Recreation Room, Study, Storage
Features
Beamed Ceilings, Breakfast Bar, Built-in Features, Cathedral Ceiling(s), Chandelier, Closet System, Coffered Ceiling(s), Crown Molding, Double Vanity, Granite Counters, Kitchen Island, Separate Shower, Solid Surface Counters, Walk-In Closet(s), Wet Bar, Primary on Main

Outside

Construction
Other, Stone
Roof
Asphalt/Comp Shingle
Garage
3 Car Attached, Paved
Porches and decks
Covered Patio, Patio, Porch, Screened Porch
Lot
Irrigation System, Lake Pump, Landscaped
Topography
Gentle Slope,Level

Systems

Cooling
Central Air, Multiple
Water
Commercial System

Community and costs

Golf membership
Golf
Community features
Boat Ramp, Boat Storage, Clubhouse, Dock, Gated, Fitness Center, Marina, Playground, Pool, Tennis Court(s), Walking Trails, Community Lake/Pond, Lake
Association fee
$2,000
The neighborhood

Living in Reynolds Lake Oconee

Buying in Reynolds comes with membership questions: which clubs, which fees, and what transfers with the house. Margie’s membership guide walks through all of it.

Read the Reynolds membership guide
Nearby in price

More Reynolds Lake Oconee Homes for Sale

See all 173 Reynolds Lake Oconee listings →
Margie Sorrell, Lake Oconee REALTOR®

Want to See 189 Reynolds Drive?

Call or text to set up a showing. I can pull the recent sales in Reynolds Lake Oconee and provide comps for you to review.

Non-commercial use only. Listing data © 2026 Lake Country Board of REALTORS® MLS. Deemed reliable but not guaranteed.